Short answer
- A clarification question resolves an unclear point in the tender documents in writing before you bid.
- In public tenders every bidder receives the same answer. Keep it neutral and ask per item.
- In German EU-wide construction tenders and in Austria, questions asked in time must be answered at least six days before the deadline.
- Never change the bill of quantities yourself: in German public tenders that leads to exclusion.
As of 15 November 2026 · not legal advice
What is a tender clarification question?
A clarification question is a written question about the tender documents that a bidder asks before submitting a bid. In Germany, such information must be given to all companies without delay and in the same way (Section 12a(4) VOB/A). The Swiss Public Procurement Ordinance calls them «questions about the tender documents» (Art. 8 VöB).
As a manufacturer or distributor you often receive a bill of quantities not from the authority but from a contractor or planner. In that case, you ask the sender. The logic stays the same: clarify first, then price. How requests reach you and get captured is covered in Tender requests from the email inbox.
Why ask instead of assuming?
Because a silent assumption can cost you the whole bid in a public tender. In Germany, changes to the tender documents are not allowed (Section 13(1) no. 5 VOB/A), and bids that make them are excluded (Section 16(1) no. 2 VOB/A).
Even outside procurement law, an assumption has a price. Price the thinner board and you are cheaper, but possibly wrong. Price the thicker one and you are right, but possibly too expensive. A written answer takes that bet off the table.
A good clarification question turns an assumption into a requirement that applies to every bidder.
Which ambiguities are worth a question?
Any that change price, quantity or product choice. Keep these six patterns in mind while going through the bill of quantities:
- Short and long text disagree: for example on thickness, class or dimensions. Which text is binding is explained in Analysing a bill of quantities with AI.
- Quantity or unit is missing or does not fit: for example pieces where only an area makes sense.
- The named product is not available: or it is unclear what counts as equivalent. How to offer alternatives properly is covered in Winning with alternates.
- A technical requirement is missing: such as class, colour or finish, without which you cannot pick a specific product.
- The item type is unclear: for example a contingency item without quantity. The types are explained in Bill of quantities item types.
- A reference leads nowhere: the item mentions a drawing, annex or preamble that is missing from the documents.
You do not need to ask if the documents already contain the answer, for example in the preamble or in earlier answers from the authority. Read those first, or you lose time before the question deadline.
By when do you have to ask?
Early enough for the answer to arrive before the deadline named in the tender documents. The contracting authority may set a cut-off date for questions (Art. 8 VöB). For the answer, these rules apply by country:
| Country | Answer at the latest | Legal basis |
|---|---|---|
| DE, EU-wide | 6 calendar days before deadline | § 12a EU VOB/A |
| DE, national | without delay, to all | § 12a VOB/A |
| AT | 6 days, accelerated 4 | § 69 BVergG |
| CH, federal | a few working days after cut-off | Art. 8 VöB |
All deadlines apply only if the question was asked in time. Cantons, federal states and utilities may have their own rules.
If an answer requested in time arrives later than six calendar days before the deadline in a German EU-wide construction tender, the authority must extend the bid deadline. This does not apply if the information is irrelevant or was requested too late (Section 10a EU(6) VOB/A). For supplies and services, the same rule is set out in Section 20(3) VgV.
So plan backwards: the question deadline minus review time gives you the day by which your team must have gone through the bill of quantities. Whether the bid is worth it at all is best decided beforehand, for example with the framework in Bid or no bid?.
How do you word a clarification question?
Short, unambiguous and understandable for every bidder. Five rules help:
- One question per item. Several topics in one question lead to an answer that settles only part of it.
- Cite the reference. Tender number, lot, item number and the exact wording you refer to.
- Show the conflict, do not judge it. «Short text says 120 mm, long text 140 mm» instead of «the item is wrong».
- Offer an answer. A closed question with two options gets a faster and clearer reply than an open one.
- Reveal nothing. No product name, no price, no solution idea that helps other bidders.
Template: the six building blocks of a clarification question
| Block | Content | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Subject | Question, tender number, lot | one question per message |
| Reference | Item number, page, document | as written in the BoQ |
| Wording | Text of the passage | quote it verbatim |
| Issue | what conflicts or is missing | factual, no judgement |
| Question | two options to choose from | closed wording |
| Request | written answer to all | via the tender platform |
If the authority provides its own form or question forum, use it instead of email.
Example (fictitious): conflicting insulation thickness
Subject: Clarification question on tender 2026-117, lot 2. Reference: item 02.03.0040, bill of quantities page 14. Wording: the short text says «insulation board 120 mm», the long text «thickness 140 mm».
Question: Should the item be priced with an insulation thickness of 120 mm or 140 mm? We kindly ask for a written answer to all bidders via the tender platform.
What do you do with the answer?
You work it into your pricing and check whether the authority has changed the documents with it. Substantial changes to the tender documents also oblige the authority in German EU-wide tenders to extend the deadline (Section 10a EU(6) VOB/A, Section 20(3) VgV).
- After every answer, download the current version of the documents and compare it with yours.
- Record question, answer and date in the bid file so that colleagues in inside sales can find them too.
- If no answer comes, price according to the wording of the documents and do not change them. If variant bids are allowed, an alternative may be the right route.
- For private requests, state your assumption as a note in the quote, for example «priced with 140 mm as per long text».
Clarification question or notice of concerns: what is the difference?
The clarification question belongs to the bidding phase, the notice of concerns to execution. Under the German VOB/B, a contractor who has concerns about the intended method of execution or about supplied materials must notify the client in writing without delay, if possible before work starts (Section 4(3) VOB/B).
Whatever you clarify before bidding, you will not have to raise as a concern later. The more ambiguities a clarification question resolves, the less discussion there is after the award.
How does software help find ambiguities earlier?
It shortens the time to the first review and shows exactly where to look. Scalera uses confidence scores and flags low-confidence matches for review, so you can prioritise where to invest time or request clarification from customers (FAQ).
Items can be grouped by product category so that several people work in parallel (FAQ). Scalera recognises your own and competitor products in tenders and suggests matching items from your catalogue (FAQ); if no conversion factor is stored for a quantity, you are informed.
The flagged items are a good starting point for your list of questions. You word the question and remain responsible for it. More on matching is on the Product matching page. Scalera is used by 150+ manufacturers, distributors and general contractors across Europe.
Frequently asked questions
What is a tender clarification question?
A written question about the tender documents that you ask before submitting your bid. In public tenders the contracting authority answers it the same way for all bidders (Section 12a(4) VOB/A, Art. 8 VöB).
Will other bidders know the question came from me?
The answer goes to everyone, the sender's name does not. For Swiss federal tenders, anonymisation is explicitly required (Art. 8 VöB). Word your question so that it reveals nothing about your bid.
By when do I have to ask?
The deadline in the tender documents is decisive. If there is none, ask early enough for the answer to arrive before the six-day limit (Section 12a EU(3) VOB/A, Section 69 BVergG 2018).
May I adjust the bill of quantities in my bid if an item is unclear?
Not in German public tenders: changes to the tender documents are not allowed (Section 13(1) no. 5 VOB/A), and such bids are excluded (Section 16(1) no. 2 VOB/A). Clarify the item with a question instead.
What happens if the answer comes too late?
If you asked in time and the answer matters for the bid, the contracting authority in German EU-wide tenders has to extend the bid deadline (Section 10a EU(6) VOB/A for construction works, Section 20(3) VgV for supplies and services).
Does this also apply to requests from contractors or distributors?
The procurement deadlines only apply to public tenders. For private requests, clarify the item directly with the sender and keep the question and answer in writing.
Does Scalera detect unclear items?
Scalera uses confidence scores and flags low-confidence matches for review, which helps you decide where to invest time or request clarification from customers (FAQ).
Key takeaways
- A clarification question settles an unclear point in writing and equally for all bidders.
- Ask about anything that changes price, quantity or product choice, and read the preamble and earlier answers first.
- Deadlines: in German EU-wide construction tenders and in Austria six days for the answer; in Switzerland the cut-off in the documents applies.
- One question per item, cite the reference, offer two options, reveal nothing about your bid.
- Without an answer, the wording applies. Changing the bill of quantities yourself leads to exclusion in German public tenders.
Next steps
- Save the template with the six building blocks as a text snippet in your email client or bid folder.
- For every new bill of quantities, put the question deadline in the calendar together with the bid deadline.
- Read how item types and equivalent products change a quote: Bill of quantities item types and Winning with alternates.
- Test with one of your own bills of quantities which items Scalera flags as uncertain: Book a demo.
Disclosure: this guide is published by Scalera and is not legal advice. The tender documents and the law applicable in each case are decisive.
Sources
- German Construction Contract Procedures Part A (VOB/A), Section 1, 2019 edition: § 12a, § 13, § 16 (lxgesetze.de, German), accessed 15 Nov 2026
- VOB/A Section 2, 2026 edition (§ 10a EU, § 12a EU, § 13 EU, § 16 EU), Federal Gazette BAnz AT 24.08.2026 B6 (PDF, German), accessed 15 Nov 2026
- German Public Procurement Ordinance, § 20 VgV, gesetze-im-internet.de (German), accessed 15 Nov 2026
- Austrian Federal Procurement Act 2018, § 69 BVergG 2018, RIS Austria (German), accessed 15 Nov 2026
- Swiss Ordinance on Public Procurement (SR 172.056.11), Art. 8 VöB, fedlex.admin.ch (German), accessed 15 Nov 2026
- German Construction Contract Procedures Part B (VOB/B), 2016 edition, § 4 VOB/B (lxgesetze.de, German), accessed 15 Nov 2026
- Scalera, FAQ and Product matching, accessed 15 Nov 2026
- Example: fictitious values for illustration
