Short answer
- Main bid: an offer for the scope exactly as tendered.
- Alternative bid (DE: Nebenangebot, AT: Alternativangebot, CH: variant): your own proposal; whether it counts depends on the permission.
- Modified bid (AT) or equivalent deviation (DE): a minor technical change with proof of equivalence.
- Before submitting, check permission, minimum requirements, form and proof.
As of 17 November 2026 · Based on VOB/A, BVergG 2018 and BöB
What is a main bid?
The main bid answers the tender as it is set: same scope, same items, same conditions. In Austria it is called a tender-compliant bid.
It can also be a precondition. The contracting authority may allow alternative bids only together with a main bid (VOB/A 2026, § 8 EU para. 2 no. 3). In Austria, alternative bids are, unless stated otherwise, only allowed next to a tender-compliant bid (BVergG 2018, § 96).
May you submit several main bids?
That depends on the documents, because the authority can exclude several main bids. If you submit several, each must be ready for award on its own (VOB/A 2026, § 13 EU paras. 2 and 3, VOB/A 2026, § 16 EU para. 1).
What is an alternative bid?
An alternative bid is your own solution that deviates from the tender documents, for example a different system instead of the tendered one. That is our practical definition. Legally, permission and form decide.
In EU procedures in Germany, the authority states in the notice whether it allows, requires or excludes alternative bids. It does not need to give a reason. If the statement is missing, no alternative bids are allowed (VOB/A 2026, § 8 EU para. 2 no. 3). The implementation decree for VOB/A 2026 highlights this duty as new.
If alternative bids are allowed, the authority names the minimum requirements and the way to submit them. The award criteria must apply to main and alternative bids alike (VOB/A 2026, § 8 EU para. 2 no. 3).
What applies below the EU thresholds?
Section 1 of the VOB/A in the 2019 edition still applies there (BAnz AT 16.12.2025 B7). The authority states whether it does not allow alternative bids or allows them only with a main bid (VOB/A 2019, § 8 para. 2 no. 3). If it has not allowed them, they are to be excluded (VOB/A 2019, § 16 para. 1).
What is it called in Austria and Switzerland?
In Austria an alternative bid (Alternativangebot) is an offer for an alternative proposal by the bidder (BVergG 2018, § 2). In Switzerland a variant is any bid that reaches the goal of the procurement in a different way than planned. You may propose variants unless the contracting authority restricts or excludes them (BöB, Art. 33).
| Country | Term | No statement |
|---|---|---|
| DE, EU procedure | Nebenangebot | not allowed |
| DE, below | Nebenangebot | not excluded |
| AT | Alternativangebot | not allowed |
| CH | Variant | allowed |
Summarised from VOB/A 2026, § 8 EU para. 2 no. 3, VOB/A 2019, § 8 para. 2 no. 3, BVergG 2018, § 96 and BöB, Art. 33, retrieved 17 November 2026.
The main bid follows the tender, the alternative bid is your own proposal, and the contracting authority decides whether it counts.
What is a modified bid?
The modified bid (Abänderungsangebot) is an Austrian term. It means an offer with a minor, equivalent technical change to the tender that goes less far than an alternative bid (BVergG 2018, § 2). It is allowed unless the authority states otherwise, and it can be submitted without a tender-compliant bid (BVergG 2018, § 97).
Germany has a related rule for products. If a scope deviates from the technical specifications, it can be offered if it is equivalent in safety, health and fitness for use (VOB/A 2026, § 13 EU paras. 2 and 3). Such a bid is evaluated like a main bid (VOB/A 2026, § 16d EU para. 3). It is therefore not an alternative bid but part of the main bid.
| Term | Deviation | Condition |
|---|---|---|
| Main bid | none | as tendered |
| Alternative bid | own proposal | permission |
| Equivalent deviation | technical, minor | proof |
Summarised from VOB/A 2026, § 8 EU para. 2 no. 3, VOB/A 2026, § 13 EU paras. 2 and 3 and BVergG 2018, § 2, retrieved 17 November 2026.
Why does this matter for manufacturers and distributors?
If you supply products, you face the question in every BoQ: is my system equivalent, or a different route? Whether your bid is evaluated depends on it. These are our hints for sales.
- Equivalent product or alternative bid? A different article in one item can be an equivalent deviation, a different system for the whole trade is more likely an alternative bid (our classification). How to prove alternatives is covered in Winning with alternates.
- An optional item is not an alternative bid: the authority itself tenders an optional or alternative item. How it works is explained in Bill of quantities item types explained.
- Unclear permission: if the statement is missing or the documents contradict each other, clear it before the deadline with a bidder question (Tender clarification questions).
- File format: in the GAEB world there is a separate phase for alternative bids. How the phases fit together is covered in GAEB, ÖNORM, NPK.
Checks before an alternative bid
This list helps before you submit an alternative.
- Read the permission: does the notice or invitation state whether alternative bids are allowed, required or excluded? Without a statement they count as not allowed in EU procedures (VOB/A 2026, § 8 EU para. 2 no. 3).
- Check minimum requirements and the way to submit: are alternative bids only possible together with a main bid (VOB/A 2026, § 8 EU para. 2 no. 3)?
- Include a complete main bid if required, and price both bids separately.
- Keep the form: alternative bids belong on a separate annex, must be clearly marked, and their number is listed at the place the authority names (VOB/A 2026, § 13 EU paras. 2 and 3).
- Name the deviation: for equivalent scopes, state the deviation clearly and prove equivalence with the bid (VOB/A 2026, § 13 EU paras. 2 and 3).
- Watch the award criteria: they apply to main and alternative bids, so you are measured against the same criteria (VOB/A 2026, § 8 EU para. 2 no. 3).
What does this mean for Scalera?
According to the Scalera website, Scalera shows a reason and the AI confidence for each product suggestion (product matching). According to the FAQ you select the AI's alternatives with one click on the suggestion (Scalera FAQ). That shows you per item how well an article fits before you decide whether a deviation is needed.
Whether Scalera drafts an alternative bid or checks the permission, the website does not say. You clarify that best with your own BoQ in a demo call.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a main bid and an alternative bid?
The main bid offers the scope as tendered. An alternative bid is your own proposal that deviates from it. The contracting authority decides whether it allows, requires or excludes alternative bids (VOB/A 2026, § 8 EU para. 2 no. 3).
Is a variant the same as an alternative bid?
In essence yes, only the name changes by country. In Austria it is called Alternativangebot, an offer for an alternative proposal by the bidder (BVergG 2018, § 2). Swiss law speaks of variants (BöB, Art. 33). In Germany it is called Nebenangebot.
May I submit an alternative bid if the documents say nothing about it?
Not in EU procedures in Germany: if the statement is missing, no alternative bids are allowed (VOB/A 2026, § 8 EU para. 2 no. 3). The same applies to alternative bids in Austria (BVergG 2018, § 96). Also read the contract notice. If in doubt, submit a bidder question.
What happens to an alternative bid that is not allowed or has the wrong form?
In EU procedures in Germany it is excluded. This covers alternative bids that are not allowed, that fall below the minimum requirements, or that are not made on a separate annex and marked (VOB/A 2026, § 16 EU para. 1).
Is an equivalent product an alternative bid?
Not necessarily. A scope that deviates from the technical specifications can be offered if it is equivalent. The deviation must be clearly stated and equivalence proven. Such a bid is evaluated like a main bid (VOB/A 2026, § 13 EU paras. 2 and 3, VOB/A 2026, § 16d EU para. 3). How to choose the product is covered in Winning with alternates.
Does Scalera create alternative bids?
The Scalera website does not say so. It describes that Scalera shows a reason and the AI confidence for each product suggestion and that you can select the AI's alternatives directly (product matching, FAQ). Whether an alternative bid is allowed, you check in the tender documents.
Key takeaways
- The main bid follows the tender, the alternative bid (AT: Alternativangebot, CH: variant) is your own proposal.
- In EU procedures in Germany and in Austria, alternatives without a statement are not allowed, in Switzerland variants are allowed in principle.
- Equivalent technical deviations are part of the main bid in Germany and a modified bid in Austria.
- Before submitting, check permission, minimum requirements, form and proof of equivalence.
Next steps
- In your next BoQ, first read the statement on alternative bids in the notice and cover letter.
- Collect proof for equivalent products before the deadline: Winning with alternates.
- Test with your own BoQ how Scalera suggests alternatives: Book a demo.
Transparency note: Scalera publishes this glossary. The legal statements come from the official texts, the statements about Scalera from the website. For a specific procedure only the tender documents count; if in doubt, seek legal advice.
Sources
- Bundesanzeiger: VOB/A sections 2 and 3, 2026 edition (BAnz AT 24.08.2026 B6), § 8 EU, § 13 EU, § 16 EU, § 16d EU, retrieved 17 November 2026
- Implementation decree for VOB/A sections 2 and 3 (binding since 8 September 2026), retrieved 17 November 2026
- Bundesanzeiger: VOB/A section 1, 2019 edition (BAnz AT 16.12.2025 B7); wording: LX Gesetze, § 8, § 13, § 16 (secondary source), retrieved 17 November 2026
- RIS: BVergG 2018, § 2, § 96 and § 97, retrieved 17 November 2026
- Fedlex: BöB (SR 172.056.1), as of 1 January 2026, Art. 33, retrieved 17 November 2026
- Scalera, product matching and FAQ, retrieved 17 November 2026
