Short answer
- When you bid, you accept the contract terms. Check them before you price, not after the award.
- Look for three clauses first: contractual penalty, warranty and securities. Then dates, liability and obligations passed down to you.
- Compare each clause with the law and with your own terms of supply or purchase. The difference is your risk.
- Rate each risk by its maximum amount and decide: price it in, clarify it with a tender question or do not bid.
As of 18 November 2026. Not legal advice.
Why do contract risks belong before pricing?
Because your bid binds you to the terms of the tender. Whatever the special conditions of contract say becomes part of the contract on award, even if the bill of quantities has no line for it. You may not change the tender documents (Section 13(1) no. 5 VOB/A). So you clarify unclear points before submission with a tender clarification question.
Manufacturers and distributors face a second layer. If you quote to a general contractor or installer, they pass obligations from their construction contract down to you. Whether a project is worth it at all is decided earlier with a bid/no-bid review. This article starts after that: with the contract text.
Which clauses should you look for first?
Six clauses decide whether a job gets more expensive after the award than you priced. The table shows the question to ask of the text.
| Clause | Question | Why costly |
|---|---|---|
| Penalty | Daily rate? Cap? | Due without loss |
| Warranty | How long? From when? | Longer than your supplier's |
| Securities | How much? Which form? | Ties up liquidity |
| Dates | Fixed or approximate? | Triggers the penalty |
| Liability | Capped or open? | No ceiling |
| Flow-down | Does the main contract apply to you? | Someone else's duties |
Own presentation. Legal basis in the following sections.
How do you check a contractual penalty?
With three questions: what triggers it, how high is it per day and where is the cap. Without a cap, the risk is open-ended. Flag this finding first.
What applies in Germany?
The penalty is forfeited as soon as you are in default (Section 339 BGB). Where the VOB/B applies, daily rates count working days only (Section 11(3) VOB/B). If the client accepts the performance, it can only claim the penalty if it reserves the right on acceptance (Section 341(3) BGB, Section 11(4) VOB/B).
Case law sets a limit on the amount: in standard construction contracts a cap of up to 5% of the contract sum is acceptable, while 10% unreasonably disadvantages the contractor (BGH, judgment of 23 Jan 2003). Public clients should only agree penalties if missing a deadline can cause significant disadvantages (Section 9a VOB/A).
One detail matters for suppliers acting as merchants: a court can reduce a disproportionately high penalty under Section 343 BGB. This does not apply to a penalty promised by a merchant in the course of trade (Section 348 HGB). If you act as a merchant, the agreed penalty applies without this option to reduce it.
What applies in Switzerland and Austria?
In Switzerland the amount of the penalty can be agreed freely, and a court reduces excessive penalties at its discretion (Art. 163 CO). The penalty is due even if no loss occurred (Art. 161 CO). A penalty for late performance can be claimed in addition to performance, as long as the creditor does not accept performance without reservation (Art. 160(2) CO).
Austria regulates the penalty in Section 1336 ABGB: for missing the performance date it can be claimed in addition to performance. If the debtor proves it is excessive, the court moderates it. The creditor can also claim any loss above the penalty.
| Country | Amount | Reduction |
|---|---|---|
| Germany | Standard terms: max. 5% | Not for merchants |
| Switzerland | Freely agreed | Court reduces |
| Austria | Can be agreed | Court moderates |
| England | Proportionate | Otherwise unenforceable |
Sources: BGH, VII ZR 210/01, Section 348 HGB, Art. 163 CO, Section 1336 ABGB, UK Supreme Court, Cavendish v Makdessi. Simplified overview, not legal advice.
And outside the DACH region?
Every country has its own rules. One example: in England a penalty is unenforceable if it imposes a detriment on the party in breach out of all proportion to any legitimate interest of the innocent party. The UK Supreme Court decided this in 2015 (Cavendish v Makdessi, UKSC 2013/0280). For projects abroad, first check which law the contract chooses.
A penalty without a cap is not small print. It is an open item in your pricing.
Where does the gap between supplier and construction contract arise?
At the start of the periods. In a construction contract, the limitation period for defect claims starts on acceptance of the works (Section 634a(2) BGB). In the sales contract with your supplier it starts on delivery of the goods (Section 438(2) BGB). If months pass between delivery and acceptance, your recourse ends earlier than your own liability.
In Germany the length is the same for building materials: five years if the item was used for a building and caused its defect (Section 438(1) no. 2 BGB), and five years for the building (Section 634a(1) no. 2 BGB). If the VOB/B is agreed without its own period, it is four years for buildings (Section 13(4) VOB/B). If the construction contract demands more, you carry the difference when your supplier only owes the statutory period.
Distributors in a supply chain get some relief: for newly manufactured goods, claims against their own supplier expire no earlier than two months after the distributor has met its buyer's claims (Section 445b(2) BGB).
| Country | Sale (supplier) | Building |
|---|---|---|
| Germany | 5 years from delivery | 5 years from acceptance, VOB/B 4 |
| Switzerland | 5 years from delivery | 5 years from acceptance |
| Austria | 2 years (movable) from handover | 3 years (immovable) from handover |
Sale: building materials built into a building that caused its defect. Sources: Section 438 and Section 634a BGB, Section 13 VOB/B, Art. 210 and 371 CO, Section 933 and Section 1167 ABGB.
In Austria the same rule applies to sales and works: two years for movable and three years for immovable items, each from handover (Section 933 ABGB, Section 1167 ABGB). The parties can shorten or extend the periods. So check the period that actually appears in the contract.
What does the Swiss construction defects reform change for suppliers?
Since 1 January 2026, Switzerland has a 60-day notice period for defects of an item that was built into immovable works and caused their defect. Hidden defects must be notified within 60 days of discovery, and shorter agreed periods are void (Art. 201(4) CO). The same period applies to the immovable works themselves (Art. 367(1bis) CO).
For you as a supplier, this means: a clause in your terms of sale that sets a shorter notice period for such defects no longer works. The limitation period stays at five years from delivery (Art. 210(2) CO). For comparison: in Germany a merchant must give notice of defects without undue delay after delivery (Section 377 HGB).
Which securities do construction contracts require?
The VOB distinguishes two securities: one for performance of the contract and one for defect claims (Section 9c VOB/A). Where the VOB/B applies and nothing else is agreed, security can be a retention, a cash deposit or a guarantee, and you choose the form (Section 17(2) and (3) VOB/B). If the security is retained from payments, each payment may be reduced by at most 10% (Section 17(6) VOB/B).
If the contract sum is below EUR 250,000 excluding VAT, public clients in Germany waive security for performance. Above that, it should not exceed 5% of the contract sum, and security for defect claims should not exceed 3% of the final account (Section 9c VOB/A, Part 1). Unused security for defects must be returned after two years unless agreed otherwise (Section 17(8) VOB/B).
So check three points: the amount in percent, the form and the date of return. A guarantee for the full warranty period can tie up your credit line for years.
Which clauses does the contractor pass down to you?
If you supply a general contractor or installer, check the purchase order for references. If it only says “The terms of the main contract also apply to the supplier”, you take on penalty, warranty and dates without knowing the main contract. Ask for it, or have the clauses named one by one.
Worked example (fictitious): penalty on a partial delivery
A general contractor orders facade elements worth EUR 400,000. The order adopts from the main contract 0.2% of the contract sum per working day, capped at 5%. That is EUR 800 per working day of delay, and the cap of EUR 20,000 is reached after 25 working days.
If the purchase order refers to the sum of the main contract instead of yours, the same rate applies to a larger amount. So always check which sum the percentage refers to. And check whether your own delivery date is agreed as fixed or as estimated.
How do you rate contract risks?
With a fixed sequence of five steps, so every tender is checked the same way.
- Record the location: document, section and wording of each relevant clause.
- Compare with the benchmark: the law, an agreed standard such as the VOB/B and your own terms of supply or purchase.
- Calculate the maximum amount: penalty cap, size of the security, length of the extra liability.
- Rate it: high if the amount is open or exceeds your margin; medium if it is capped but not priced in; low if it matches the law.
- Decide: price it in, clarify it with a tender question or do not bid. Record the decision in the project.
Pricing form and quantity risk belong in this review too. How unit prices and lump sums share the risk is explained in Unit price, total price, lump sum.
How does Scalera support risk analysis?
Scalera checks tender and contract documents for critical clauses such as contractual penalties and guarantees, and against standards, laws and occupational safety rules in the DACH region. Documents can be PDF, scan, GAEB, Excel or email (Scalera, risk analysis).
Every risk is rated and added to a checklist that your team goes through before submission. You can ask Atlas about any passage. Whether you bid is your decision, and your legal expert still reviews contracts (Scalera, risk analysis). According to the product page, 150+ companies trust Scalera.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between Vertragsstrafe and Konventionalstrafe?
None in substance. The German Civil Code says Vertragsstrafe (Section 339 BGB), the Swiss Code of Obligations and the Austrian Civil Code say Konventionalstrafe (Art. 160 CO, Section 1336 ABGB). Both mean an amount agreed in advance for the case that a performance is not delivered, or not on time.
How high can a penalty in a construction contract be?
In Germany, the Federal Court of Justice accepts a cap of up to 5% of the contract sum in standard construction contracts, but not 10% (BGH, VII ZR 210/01). In Switzerland the amount can be agreed freely, and a court reduces excessive penalties (Art. 163 CO).
Do I have to pay a penalty if there was no loss?
Under Swiss law, yes: the penalty is due even if the creditor suffered no loss (Art. 161(1) CO). In Germany, too, the penalty is forfeited once you are in default, without proof of loss (Section 339 BGB).
Can I have an excessive penalty reduced afterwards?
In Switzerland and Austria a court can reduce or moderate excessive penalties (Art. 163(3) CO, Section 1336(2) ABGB). In Germany, the reduction under Section 343 BGB does not apply to a penalty promised by a merchant in the course of trade (Section 348 HGB).
When does the warranty period for building materials start?
In a sales contract on delivery of the goods, in a construction contract only on acceptance of the works (Section 438(2) BGB, Section 634a(2) BGB). The Swiss Code of Obligations follows the same logic (Art. 210 and 371 CO).
What is an on-demand guarantee?
A guarantee under which the guarantor pays immediately on request. Objections to the claim can only be settled afterwards. Where the VOB/B applies, the client cannot demand such a guarantee (Section 17(4) VOB/B).
Does an AI review replace a legal review of the contract?
No. Software can find, flag and rate clauses. Whether a contract is acceptable is your decision, together with your legal expert (Scalera, risk analysis).
Does Scalera also check tenders in other languages?
Yes. According to the product page, Scalera reads tenders in German, English, French, Italian, Spanish and other European languages (Scalera, risk analysis). What to watch for in foreign-language tenders is covered in Foreign-language BoQs.
Key takeaways
- Contract risks sit in the preliminaries and conditions of contract, not in the BoQ. Check them before pricing.
- For penalties, the daily rate, the cap and the reference sum matter. Without a cap, the risk is open.
- As a merchant in Germany, you cannot have an agreed penalty reduced under Section 343 BGB.
- Warranty starts on delivery with your supplier and on acceptance in the construction contract. That is the gap.
- Since 2026, Switzerland applies a 60-day notice period to built-in construction products.
Next steps
- Create a checklist with the six clauses and use it for every tender.
- Compare your terms of sale and purchase with the periods in this article, especially after the Swiss reform.
- See how Scalera flags and rates clauses: Risk analysis or Book a demo.
Transparency note: this article is published by Scalera and is not legal advice. The contract and the law applicable in each case are decisive.
Sources
- Federal Court of Justice (BGH), press release no. 044/2003 on VII ZR 210/01, judgment of 23 Jan 2003, accessed 18 Nov 2026
- BGB Section 339, 341, 343, 438, 445b, 634a; HGB Section 348, 377, gesetze-im-internet.de, accessed 18 Nov 2026
- VOB/B Section 11, 13, 17; VOB/A Part 1 (2019 edition) Section 9a, 9c, 13, dejure.org (secondary source), accessed 18 Nov 2026
- Swiss Code of Obligations (SR 220), Art. 160–163, 201, 210, 367, 371, Fedlex, status 1 October 2026, accessed 18 Nov 2026
- Austrian Civil Code (ABGB) Section 933, 1167, 1336, RIS, accessed 18 Nov 2026
- UK Supreme Court, Cavendish Square Holding BV v Talal El Makdessi, judgment of 4 Nov 2015, accessed 18 Nov 2026
- Scalera, Risk analysis, accessed 18 Nov 2026
- Worked example: fictitious, for illustration
