Articles

Discounts, early payment and freight: comparing quotes

In a quote comparison, what counts is not the figure in the price column but the amount for the goods delivered to your site. Add up stacked discounts, forget freight or bake in the early payment discount, and you award to the wrong supplier. Four calculation steps and a separate early payment column make the comparison reliable.

Abstract illustration: two quote sheets with a percent sign on the left, a balance scale in the middle, a delivery van next to a stack of coins on the right.
Introduction
Apply discounts one after the other, spread freight and unloading across the items and keep early payment discounts in a separate column.

33.5%

total discount from 30% and 5% applied in sequence, not 35% (calculation in the article)

11

rules make up the International Chamber of Commerce's Incoterms 2020 for place of delivery, costs and risk (ICC)

Separate

column for early payment discounts: in German public works tenders, unsolicited ones are not taken into account (§ 16d(4) VOB/A)

60 days

payment term: longer terms are only valid in Germany if expressly agreed and not grossly unfair (§ 271a(1) BGB)

Short answer

  • Compare quotes by the amount you pay for the delivered goods, not by the list price.
  • Apply stacked discounts one after the other: 30% and 5% give 33.5%, not 35%.
  • Spread freight, surcharges and unloading across the items. Keep early payment discounts in a separate column.
  • Check who unloads for every quote. Under Incoterms 2020 the seller does not unload with DAP, but does with DPU.

As of 16 November 2026 · not legal or tax advice

Why is the unit price not enough for a quote comparison?

Because two similar unit prices can lead to very different invoice amounts. Discounts, freight, surcharges and payment terms sit in different places in a quote: in the line item, in the footer or in the delivery terms.

How to compare quotes line by line is covered in the guide Bid comparison in construction. This article deals with the next step: converting all commercial terms so that the columns are truly comparable. The price types in the bill of quantities are explained in Unit price, total price, lump sum.

Which commercial terms change the comparison price?

Every term that changes the amount you pay or the risk you carry. These seven belong in every price comparison:

Commercial terms in supplier quotes and where they go in the price comparison
TermAffectsIn the comparison
DiscountPrice per unitinclude
SurchargeItem or orderinclude
FreightOrderspread across items
UnloadingYour own costadd as cost
Early paymentPaymentseparate column
ValidityYour risknote end date
Price clauseYour riskflag

Compiled by the editorial team. Surcharges include, for example, small-quantity or cutting surcharges. Which term applies is set by the quote and your purchasing conditions.

How do you get from list price to comparison price?

In four steps, in the same order for every supplier:

  1. Net price per unit: list price minus all discounts, applied one after the other.
  2. Goods value: net price times the quantity in the bill of quantities. If the sales unit differs from the unit in the bill of quantities, convert first (Units of measure conversion).
  3. Additional costs: spread freight, surcharges and your own unloading costs across the items, for example by goods value.
  4. Early payment discount: keep it in a separate column, not in the comparison price.

Why you must not add discounts together

Because the second discount applies to the already reduced price. 30% and 5% become 0.70 × 0.95 = 0.665. You pay 66.5% of the list price, so the total discount is 33.5%, not 35%.

For 1,500 m² at a list price of €24.00, that is €23,940.00 instead of €23,400.00. Adding the discounts makes the supplier look €540.00 cheaper than they are.

Compare the amount that leaves your account for the delivered goods, not the figure in the price column.

Does the early payment discount belong in the comparison price?

No, keep it in a separate column. Whether you get it depends on your accounts team paying within the discount period. If you bake it in and pay late, your comparison no longer holds.

Procurement law also keeps early payment discounts apart from the price. The German VOB/A calls them “price reductions with conditions for the payment period” and does not take unsolicited ones into account when evaluating bids in public works tenders (§ 16d(4) VOB/A). Under a VOB/B contract, deductions for early payment that were not agreed are not permitted (§ 16(5) no. 2 VOB/B).

Read early payment and payment terms together

One supplier offers 2% for payment within 10 days, another offers no discount but 60 days to pay. Which is worth more depends on your cash position, not on the price comparison. In Germany, a payment term of more than 60 days is only valid if it is expressly agreed and not grossly unfair to the creditor (§ 271a(1) BGB).

How do you compare freight and delivery terms?

By recording, for every quote, where delivery ends and who unloads. A phrase like “delivered to site” does not settle that on its own. Ask whether the price includes unloading.

For cross-border deliveries, the Incoterms rules of the International Chamber of Commerce help. The 2020 edition has eleven three-letter rules. All costs of a rule are listed together in article A9/B9 (ICC, Incoterms 2020).

On a construction site, the difference between DAP and DPU matters because it settles who unloads: under DAP the seller does not unload the goods, under DPU the seller does (ICC, Incoterms 2020). If a supplier delivers DAP, plan your own crane, forklift or labour and include the cost in the comparison.

  • Freight as a flat fee, per tonne or per delivery?
  • Small-quantity surcharge below a certain amount?
  • Partial deliveries possible, and at extra cost?
  • Delivery date in line with the construction schedule?

Worked example (fictional): insulation boards for a facade

A contractor compares two quotes for 1,500 m² of thermal insulation boards. Supplier A delivers DAP, and unloading with the contractor's own crane costs €190.00. Supplier B delivers DPU and unloads.

Fictional comparison of two quotes, amounts in euros
LineSupplier ASupplier B
List price per m²24.0021.60
Discount30% + 5%25%
Net price per m²15.9616.20
Goods value23,940.0024,300.00
Freight450.00included
Unloading190.00included
Comparison price24,580.0024,300.00
Early payment 2%−487.80none
With early payment24,092.2024,300.00

All figures fictional. Early payment discount calculated on goods value plus freight (€24,390.00). Unloading is the contractor's own cost and is not invoiced by the supplier.

By net price per m², supplier A is ahead. By comparison price, supplier B is €280.00 cheaper. Only if you pay A's invoice within the discount period does the result flip: A is then €207.80 cheaper.

So the decision hinges on a question that is in neither quote: does your accounts payable team reliably pay within ten days? That is exactly why the early payment discount sits on its own line.

What do you do about short validity or price clauses?

Note the end date of every quote and compare it with your own commitment to the client. In German public works tenders, the bid validity period starts when the submission period ends and should only exceed 30 calendar days in justified cases (§ 10(4) and (5) VOB/A).

If a supplier quote is valid for less time than your own commitment, you carry the price risk until the contract is awarded. Flag those quotes and ask for an extension before you submit. If a quote contains a clause such as “price on day of delivery”, the price is not fixed and should be marked as a risk.

How do you keep commercial terms traceable in the price comparison?

With a fixed column for each term and a reference to where it appears in the quote. That way you can still see weeks later where every figure came from.

  • One column per term instead of free-text notes.
  • Source with page or line of the quote and the date of the version.
  • One rule for spreading freight, applied to every supplier in the same way.
  • Mark missing details as “missing” and ask, instead of estimating.

This is easiest if you ask for the terms in the request itself. What structured requests look like is shown in Automate supplier price requests. How to follow up on missing answers is covered in Tracking supplier quote responses.

Where does software help, and what does your team decide?

Software takes over the coordination, while judging the commercial terms stays with you. Scalera analyses the bill of quantities and assigns items to suitable suppliers and subcontractors. Existing framework agreements, regional responsibilities and preferences are taken into account (Supplier Matching).

From the assignment, Scalera generates ready-to-send RFQs with a structured item overview and the relevant attachments. It then tracks responses and sends automatic reminders for missing quotes (Supplier Matching). Which term tips the balance is for your purchasing team to decide. Scalera is used by 150+ manufacturers, dealers and general contractors across Europe.

Frequently asked questions

How do I calculate a total discount from several discounts?

Multiply the remaining shares and subtract the result from 100%. For 30% and 5% that is 0.70 × 0.95 = 0.665, so a total discount of 33.5%. Adding the discounts overstates the reduction.

Does an early payment discount belong in the price comparison?

Yes, but in a separate column and not in the comparison price. In German public works tenders, unsolicited early payment discounts are not taken into account when bids are evaluated (§ 16d(4) VOB/A).

Can I deduct an early payment discount that was not agreed?

Not under a VOB/B contract: deductions for early payment that were not agreed are not permitted (§ 16(5) no. 2 VOB/B). Put the rate and the period in writing in your purchase order.

What is the difference between DAP and DPU?

Both Incoterms rules deliver to a named place. Under DAP the seller does not unload the goods, under DPU the seller does (ICC, Incoterms 2020). With DAP, add your own crane, forklift or labour to the comparison.

How do I spread freight costs across the items?

Pick one rule, for example by goods value or by weight, and apply it to every supplier in the same way. Which rule you choose matters less than making sure freight is not missing from the comparison.

What if a quote does not mention freight?

Ask the supplier and mark the cell as “missing” until you have an answer. Do not estimate the freight yourself, or you end up comparing your assumption instead of their quote.

How long can a payment term be?

In Germany, a payment term of more than 60 days is only valid if it is expressly agreed and not grossly unfair to the creditor (§ 271a(1) BGB). Tighter limits apply to public contracting authorities (§ 271a(2) BGB).

How does Scalera support quote comparison?

Scalera assigns bill of quantities items to suitable suppliers and subcontractors, generates ready-to-send RFQs, tracks responses and sends reminders for missing quotes (Supplier Matching). Your team sets the calculation rules for commercial terms.

Key takeaways

  • The comparison price is the amount for the goods delivered to site, not the list price.
  • Multiply stacked discounts: 30% and 5% give 33.5%.
  • Freight, surcharges and your own unloading costs go into the comparison price, early payment discounts into a separate column.
  • Incoterms 2020 settle place of delivery and costs. Under DAP the seller does not unload, under DPU the seller does.
  • Validity and price clauses are risks that you flag visibly in the price comparison.

Next steps

  • Add one column each for freight, unloading, early payment discount and validity to your price comparison template.
  • Ask for these terms in your next price request.
  • Read how to compare quotes line by line: Bid comparison in construction.
  • See with your own bill of quantities how Scalera coordinates requests and responses: Book a demo.

Disclosure: This article is published by Scalera and is not legal or tax advice. What counts is the quote, your purchasing conditions and the law that applies in each case.

Sources

  1. German Construction Contract Procedures Part A, Section 1, 2019 edition: § 16d, § 10 (lxgesetze.de), accessed 16 Nov 2026
  2. German Construction Contract Procedures Part B, 2016 edition: § 16 (lxgesetze.de), accessed 16 Nov 2026
  3. German Civil Code, § 271a BGB, gesetze-im-internet.de, accessed 16 Nov 2026
  4. International Chamber of Commerce, Incoterms 2020, iccwbo.org, accessed 16 Nov 2026
  5. Scalera, Supplier Matching, accessed 16 Nov 2026
  6. Worked example: fictional figures for illustration