Method comparison, as of 19 November 2026. Note: Scalera publishes this page and offers AI order entry. Technical statements on OCR are backed by Wikipedia articles, Scalera features by pages on scalera.ai. We do not name other vendors.
Short answer
- OCR reads characters: the technology turns a scan or photo into text, but not yet into a sales order.
- Template OCR works with fixed layouts; every new customer layout needs a new template.
- 99% is not enough: a 1% character error rate can mean 5% or more incorrect words (Wikipedia, OCR).
- AI reads orders: line items, quantities and articles from your catalogue, with a confidence score per match (Scalera, Order processing).
- Test fairly: measure error-free lines in the ERP, not character accuracy.
For back office, order processing and IT teams at building materials distributors, manufacturers and suppliers.
What sets OCR, template OCR and AI apart?
OCR stands for optical character recognition. The method converts images of text, for example from a scan or photo, into machine-encoded text (Wikipedia, Optical character recognition). The result is a string of characters, not a data record.
For forms, ICR was added: the recognition of hand-printed characters. ICR works best when the characters sit in clearly separated fields (Wikipedia, Intelligent character recognition). Handwriting on paper or in a scan counts as offline handwriting recognition, a branch of text recognition (Wikipedia (German), Handschrifterkennung). Template OCR builds on this logic of fixed fields: for each layout you define where order number, quantity and article number sit.
AI order entry treats the order as a whole. The AI recognises which line is an item, reads quantity and description and matches the item to an article in your catalogue (Scalera, Order processing).
Template OCR and AI side by side
The table compares both approaches on six points that matter for incoming orders.
| Point | Template OCR | AI capture |
|---|---|---|
| Result | Text from the image | Order with line items |
| New layout | New template needed | Any format, photos too |
| Handwriting | Block letters in fixed fields | Added lines too |
| Email text | No image, OCR does not help | Read as well |
| Article | Character by character | Matched to catalogue |
| Uncertainty | Threshold per character | Confidence per line |
Sources: OCR column based on Wikipedia (OCR, ICR, Texterkennung), retrieved 19 November 2026; AI column based on scalera.ai/en/order-processing. Vendors may combine features; always test with your own orders.
Why is high character accuracy not enough?
Because a sales order consists of words and numbers, not single characters. If a word only counts when every letter is right, a character error rate of 1% can lead to 5% or more incorrect words (Wikipedia, Optical character recognition).
For article numbers the calculation is simple. At 99% character accuracy, an 8-character number is error-free with a probability of 0.99 to the power of 8, about 92.3%. Roughly one number in 13 therefore contains at least one wrong character (own calculation, assuming independent errors).
On top of that, dictionary-based correction barely helps with numbers. Text recognition should precisely not turn an alphanumeric combination such as “8te” into a word (Wikipedia (German), Texterkennung), and according to the same source, lists of numbers need to be proofread several times.
OCR answers the question “What does it say?”. Order entry needs the answer to “Which article is meant?”.
Where does OCR reach its limits with orders?
1
New customer layout
The customer changes systems, and the fields move to a different place.
Check: template per layout
2
8 instead of B
In an article number, a B becomes an 8; no dictionary catches it.
Check: catalogue match
3
Handwritten line
The printout carries an extra item, added by hand.
Check: is it captured?
4
Customer wording
The customer writes “gutter 100 galvanised” instead of your article number.
Check: match to article
Case 4 shows the core issue: OCR reads the text correctly, and the article is still missing. The same applies to quantities in customer units, such as pallets instead of pieces; how to convert units cleanly is covered in Units of measure conversion in quotes.
How does AI order entry work at Scalera?
Scalera reads orders from PDF, Excel, email text, photo and scan, including handwriting (Scalera, Order processing). Orders arrive by email or upload (Scalera, Order processing).
- Match: each line is matched to an article in your catalogue, with a confidence score per match (Scalera, Order processing).
- Flag: uncertain matches are marked; your team decides before the order moves on (Scalera, Order processing).
- Capture completely: delivery date, contact person, delivery and billing address are captured too (Scalera, Order processing).
- Hand over: the checked order goes to your ERP or CRM, for example SAP S/4HANA, Microsoft Dynamics 365, Abacus or Proalpha, or as an export (Scalera, Order processing, Scalera, ERP integrations).
The catalogue match thus takes the role a dictionary would play in OCR: it checks a recognised number against what actually exists in your range. The full flow from inbox to ERP is described in Order processing automation.
When is OCR enough, and when does AI pay off?
The answer depends on your incoming orders, not on the technology. These questions help you decide:
- Template OCR is enough when a small number of customers always order in the same printed layout and use your article numbers.
- AI pays off when layouts change, orders sit in the email text, handwriting appears or customers use their own descriptions.
- No recognition is needed at all when a customer sends structured data that your ERP takes over directly.
For the quoting process, the same method comparison starts from a different point: Excel or quoting AI. How line items are read from PDF bills of quantities is shown in Bill of quantities from PDF and scan.
How do you compare both approaches fairly?
- Real sample: take orders from a normal month, including photos, scans, email text and handwritten additions.
- Right metric: count lines that reach the ERP with the right article and quantity, not recognised characters.
- Measure review effort: record how many lines are flagged for review and how long the review takes.
- Plan for new layouts: include orders from customers whose format has not appeared in the test yet.
- Lead time: measure the time from incoming order to order confirmation.
A general test plan for AI software is in Pilot AI tender software; how requests are captured from the inbox is shown in Tender requests from the email inbox. Clean article master data makes every match easier, see Datanorm, BMEcat and ETIM.
Key takeaways
- OCR turns an image into text; a sales order also needs line items, quantities and the right article.
- Template OCR suits fixed layouts; every new layout needs a new template.
- Character accuracy is misleading: a 1% character error rate can mean 5% or more word errors (Wikipedia, OCR).
- AI capture matches every line to your catalogue and flags uncertain matches (Scalera, Order processing).
- A fair test measures error-free lines in the ERP and the time to order confirmation.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between OCR and AI in order entry?
OCR converts images of printed or handwritten text into machine-encoded text (Wikipedia, Optical character recognition). AI order entry goes further: the AI recognises the line items, matches each one to an article in your catalogue and shows a confidence score for every match (Scalera, Order processing).
Is 99 percent OCR accuracy enough?
Not necessarily. A character error rate of 1% can mean 5% or more errors at word level (Wikipedia, Optical character recognition). For an 8-character article number, our own calculation shows roughly one number in 13 is affected.
Can OCR read handwritten orders?
Partly. ICR reads hand-printed characters best in clearly separated fields, but it cannot read cursive handwriting because it must assess each character individually (Wikipedia, Intelligent character recognition). According to the product page, Scalera also captures handwritten additions and poor scans (Scalera, Order processing).
When is template OCR enough?
When a small number of customers always order in the same printed layout and use your own article numbers. A template describes where each field sits, so every new layout needs its own template.
How does the AI handle uncertain lines?
Scalera flags matches with a low confidence score, and your team decides before the order goes to the ERP (Scalera, Order processing).
How does the captured order get into the ERP?
Through a ready-made integration or as an export; the list of systems is on the ERP integrations page.
Next steps
Collect ten typical orders from your inbox, from a clean PDF to a photographed printout with handwriting, and run them through the five test steps. In a demo you can see how Scalera turns them into sales orders; more on the Order processing page.
